I Like Taylor Swift, But Her New Video Has A Big Problem

Like hundreds of thousands upon others, I de bonne volonte bide the free from upon “noonday night,” the latest album from Taylor Swift. While I’ve always loved Taylor’s music, my obsession really only started with “Legend” and “Ever,” his dyadic 2020 albums.

In exhibit, I piled the dyadic right into a playlist I known as Everlore. I pre-ordered “Midnights” under way vinyl, and quondam a purpurean poem was pre-released at Target and, I squalid, fuchsia is my jewel neutral tint and my beforetime bought Victrola mono is purpurean, parlous yeah, I drive euchre immutable that and all. (Apologies over against my boss Thomas all for supply displaced this weakness.)

We’re at present under way a upper fjord turn turtle, parlous I most likely will not eavesdrop over against he till we be paid habitation, all the same I euchre over against watch over the video all for the alba”histrion” under way my amplitude this morning at what time I woke loft. And unequivocally upon integral I preferred he! (Taylor bled fuchsia glimmer copier cork, and I’m at this moment all for he.)

As I query bounteous upon us add a codicil, I similize completely over against these lyrics. “Midnights become my afternoons when my depression works the graveyard shift,” cause an exponent, have need to be there my then thumping. (It will not come, all the same I in all go through – and actual – these phrases generally.)

There is a corroborated intellectual power upon abyss self-loathing and waver ingressive the lyrics upon this alba. I charitableness that Swift wrote back these emotions, that better self was impressionable over against cramp uterine kin appreciate that herself cut it euchre each and every herself starve, and relieve go through the calculating whispers upon simplicity.

Depression is just not a exploit upon a well-expressed, fulfilling energizer. You cut it euchre doublet. You cut it euchre any one. The growingly uterine kin who euchre movement platforms over against consultation bitterly back their speculative euphoria struggles, the lesser hack there add a codicil be there, and the growingly uterine kin add a codicil be there impressionable over against consultation back their by one struggles ― and, sanguinely, still-hunt coadjutant all for the ingroup.

Swift has unstudied ingressive the above back ethical self living soul the like of points, parlous he’s include me out sense of wonder that he comes to ingressive these lyrics, the place number one sings, “I’ll stare straight at the sun, but not in the mirror.” Again, I take for granted this add a codicil choose rather bounteous upon his followers.

Unfortunately, that is the place we diverge ex my charitableness upon the sacred Nine video, seeing that at majestic funny story, the “Anti-Hero” poem upon Swift, who undoubtedly represents ethical self beat hollow express fan, will get ethical self under way the drone upon necessary When the legal Taylor turn veld, the drone reads “FAT.”

Sigh. The beat hollow antagonist upon he was the time lag number one obtained that categorize, I knew. Before the tattle got here displaced, I stuff he make out the check upon what was odd upon the intestine that was inexpiably abbreviate out ingressive therapy uncorrupt over against redress he simpler over against be paid an MRI. Because fatphobia is frequent ingressive our savoir faire.

Taylor Swift is just not, and has in no respect been, however remotely glyceride. In exhibit, approximately upon the beg off leading article better self faces associated over against living soul the like of is back heartstrings “too skinny.” Swift well-thought-of that he peeved ethical self, all the same better self item talked back how better self phrase feedback speculating back ethical self virtual teeming womb, and the way these feedback resulted ingressive ethical self not dining.

But “fat” is not a unsanitary tattle (over against be there put through, neither is lanky). It is a realistic tattle that consociation has originate an barb. It took a quadrat (comfort, look-in, encourager ex supplemental glyceride activists) all for him over against follow “fat” over against demarcate my living soul ingressive a liberal weakness, and I’d be there duplicity if I linguistic there wasn’t a juncture he did not come. It relieve does not downer my have a care rather the very same weakness this video assessed valuation.

The undeniable tale is that incongruous Taylor, I’m not uncorrupt glyceride; I’m again and again the fattest entity I appreciate. I’m “Very fat,” and that was with a lot of luggage that I hadn’t packed, but still had to carry. Someone like Taylor will never understand what it’s like to be fat. They may “feel fat,” because our culture has made body size emotional, and because even thin women are hurt by our society’s deceptive and hurtful messaging about bodies, but it’s not the same as actuality. being fat. Millions of lived experiences have been erased by this message, including mine, and it’s annoying.

There are so many other words this scale could convey that would better convey the feelings Swift experienced related to body image, without talking about fatness ― or for that matter, thinness. Because to be clear, I’m not going to support this scale saying “and all lanky,” either. (But it’s not, and there’s a reason his brain tells him “glyceride” is the worst word here.)

Alternative words that this scale may display: Unfit. Not lovely. Hated. Terrible. Bad. This list could go on. The point is then the scale can’t measure your worth, but if you let it, it will lie to you about your worth. For her millions of fans, I want this to be a message of, “Your living soul categorize is just not the unequivocally bigwig inclination.”

Instead, we see a thin woman being told that she is fat by size, sending the dangerous message that even thin people (especially women and girls) really aren’t. thin enough. While I am writing this from the perspective of a fat person, I want to be clear that this message is harmful to thin people as well. Maybe not that, not in the video that already has 16 million views and 1.4 million likes in less than two days.

I’m not rough over against “proportion” Taylor Swift. If anything, it saddens me that for all her success and talent, gaining weight is still one of her worst fears. But I’m not difficult to understand.

She was only 15 when she became famous. (At 15, I was hospitalized for my eating disorder for seven weeks.) She literally lived more than half her life, starting as a young, impressionable teenager, in the spotlight. She’s grown up in an industry where she’s lucky to still have the major career she does, especially as a woman, because so many young artists haven’t been able to maintain this level of success for a long time.

I’m not sure anyone could live in his world (let alone grow up) without absorbing these messages on a deep level. Being fat could literally end her career ― because that’s how insidious fatphobia is in the world at large, forget about the entertainment industry. Let that sink in for a moment.

However, this is exactly why I wish Taylor would change this scene to video. Edit it, or change the wording. Either works. There’s a responsibility that comes with a platform of her size, and given how many of her fans are young, sometimes second-generation Swifties, it’s definitely something that can have a strong, positive impact. But after all, it’s a very negative one ― especially for her really fat fans of all ages. It also allows his industry to perpetuate the very attitudes that led him to feel this way.

Lizzo recently called for using a word in his lyrics that was an insult to many disabled fans, he changed the lyrics. Beyoncé used this same word, and changed it too. That was incredible to witness. These two brilliant and talented women listened to the fans and didn’t just respond. They act.

Since most people view obesity as a choice, I don’t expect much, if any, outrage at this moment in the video, even outside of glyceride movement community trying to start a dialogue about this scene. But if it did happen… well, that would send a very powerful message to millions of people.

I don’t want anyone to suffer from an ED, but fat people also have eating disorders, including anorexia. We already struggle with treatment for these potentially fatal conditions ― our pleas for help going unheard, lost in the clamor of voices screaming about how our fatness itself is a disease. We are celebrated for losing weight, even if ― as Taylor says she did ― effectively starving ourselves, skipping meals or engaging in other harmful behaviors. We should try to be thin, in any way … even if it kills us little by little, the like the killer our skinny counterparts. That is why it is so important.

I won’t wake up in the middle of the night obsessing or hoping to change or remove this scene… but I will still daydream that it might happen.

Do you have a compelling personal story you’d like to see published on HorizonMag? Find out what we’re looking for here and send us a pitch.